Obama Soothed. Trump Stirs. How two Presidents Have Tackled Racial Flare-Ups.
For more coverage of race, sign up right here to have our Race/Related newsletter delivered weekly to your inbox.
There was a time, not long ago, when the occupant of the White Home held a beer summit to bring with each other a white police officer and the black professor he had mistakenly arrested. An additional time, soon after the shooting death of a black teenager by a neighborhood watchman resulted in a storm of protest, that president remarked that the victim looked like he could have been his son.
When it comes to race, the most jarring distinction among the Trump presidency and that of Barack Obama is not necessarily the nature of the ugly incidents playing out across the country below their watch.
Following all, the arrests of two black men waiting at a Starbucks was preceded by Henry Louis Gates Jr., the Harvard professor, getting hauled away in handcuffs when a white neighbor thought he was breaking into his personal home. The kneeling protests at N.F.L. games followed the death of Trayvon Martin, the black teenager killed by a neighborhood watch volunteer, not to mention a string of higher-profile police shootings of unarmed black males.
The most striking difference amongst then and now is the responses of the commanders in chief, and how these reactions influence the nation&rsquos lengthy-simmering racial tensions.
President Trump sometimes uses familiar phrases that seek to evoke America&rsquos greater angels &mdash before signing a proclamation for Martin Luther King&rsquos Birthday in January, he reminded that all are created equal &ldquono matter the color of our skin.&rdquo But other words and deeds are racially inflammatory &mdash about the exact same time he referred to Haiti and some parts of Africa as &ldquoshithole countries&rdquo in closed-door remarks that had been leaked.
His predecessor, Mr. Obama, sought out a language on race that was heavy on balm. When Mr. Obama eulogized black parishioners murdered by a white supremacist at Emanuel African Methodist Church in Charleston, S.C., he famously sang &ldquoAmazing Grace.&rdquo Still, some individuals, mostly white, accused him of dividing the nation when he spoke empathetically about the racism faced by black Americans.
The divergence in the way the two men have selected to handle racial flare-ups was possibly inevitable. Mr. Obama, as the very first black president, had to overcome racism on his way to and for the duration of his time at the White Property, such as concerns more than whether he was actually born in the United States. And the quite name of his far more impulsive successor has become a type of shorthand racial taunt.
&ldquoI believe that sense that there&rsquos no leadership, there&rsquos no a single sort of guiding Americans to query and to feel about all of these tragedies that are occurring right now, tends to make it all the far more anxiety provoking,&rdquo stated Allyson Hobbs, a professor of history who is director of African and African-American studies at Stanford University.
But Mr. Obama was not with out his personal challenges when it came to leading the country&rsquos racial discourse.
When he attempted in 2009 to be crucial of the white police officer who had arrested Mr. Gates, saying that the officer had &ldquoacted stupidly,&rdquo he stirred the ire of police and conservative groups. And even in trying to backtrack and ease the flames, Mr. Obama invited far more criticism, this time from African-Americans, who believed he was being too deferential.
Attempting to heal the nation&rsquos racial wounds is an uphill battle for any president. A CNN poll taken close to the finish of Mr. Obama&rsquos presidency discovered that 54 % of Americans thought that relations in between black and white Americans had gotten worse throughout his eight years in workplace. A Pew survey from final December located that 60 % of Americans believed that Mr. Trump&rsquos election had hurt race relations.
In speaking on very charged racial incidents, Mr. Trump usually equivocates, which observers say leaves the rest of the nation fighting in circles about race. Folks typically debate whether or not what the president did or did not say was a sign that he was racist. The question then turns to regardless of whether that tends to make his supporters racist, and they in turn push back, accusing their critics of fanning racial tensions that do not exist.
Mr. Trump&rsquos most very criticized response to a racial incident came in August, right after white nationalists paraded and demonstrated in Charlottesville, Va., where they have been met by counterprotesters. Mr. Trump assigned blame for the ensuing violence to both groups and spoke of &ldquovery fine men and women on both sides.&rdquo
In other situations, he has ignored or rejected the racial tensions at the core of some high-profile, combustible public concerns.
Mr. Trump has emerged as the major critic of the practice by some N.F.L. players of kneeling in the course of the national anthem as a way to protest racial discrimination in policing. Mr. Trump personally, and successfully, lobbied some team owners, who earlier this month created a new anti-kneeling rule. He mentioned his objection to the protests had &ldquonothing to do with race,&rdquo but was rather about &ldquorespect for our nation and respect for our flag.&rdquo
This week, he took to Twitter to respond to the tweet by the tv star Roseanne Barr in which she compared a former Obama aide, Valerie Jarrett, to an ape. But Mr. Trump did not condemn the offensive tweet, or speak about race. As an alternative, he used the opportunity to complain that critics who had spoken ill of him had not apologized. The president continued on that theme on Friday morning, wondering on Twitter why Samantha Bee had not been fired from her show for making use of vulgar language to describe 1 of his daughters.
Mr. Trump manages to deftly turn racial troubles into left-appropriate political fights that are race neutral, mentioned Ernest Lyles, a black private equity companion who lives in New York. In the case of Ms. Barr&rsquos comments, for instance, Mr. Lyles said the president turned what was just an problem of somebody making a racist comment into a battle in between a liberal tv network undertaking wrong to a Republican like him.
And Mr. Lyles, 39, mentioned he identified that unfortunate due to the fact he believed that Mr. Trump could truly do more to heal the country&rsquos racial divide than Mr. Obama, simply because the men and women who listen to Mr. Trump are significantly less savvy on racial problems.
&ldquoUnfortunately, for better or worse, America is trained to be more open, and a lot more conditioned to be led by, a white male than an individual who isn&rsquot,&rdquo Mr. Lyles mentioned.
Regardless of the issues that Mr. Trump has helped fuel the nation&rsquos sometimes toxic racial climate, recent events demonstrate that there are still consequences for racial discrimination, and racist acts.
On Tuesday, the cafe chain Starbucks closed eight,000 retailers to give its workers racial sensitivity classes &mdash a response to an incident in April in which a pair of black males who had gone to a Starbucks in Philadelphia for a organization meeting were arrested on suspicion of trespassing. Starbucks had regarded itself a progressive organization, generating the incident all the more troubling.
After the arrests, the company&rsquos reputation as a place to function sank to its lowest level in at least a decade, according to YouGov BrandIndex, which tracks public perception of companies. Data from SEMrush, a Google Search analytics tool kit, shows that the number of search queries for the phrase &ldquoBoycott Starbucks&rdquo surged from a mere 500 in March to far more than 70,000 in April.
For some observers, the chain&rsquos response, nonetheless self-serving, demonstrated the expanding power of the minority consumer, a energy that retail and entertainment businesses are especially attuned to in a country whose population is anticipated to be much less than 50 % non-Hispanic white by 2045.
&ldquoAs black earnings has risen &mdash as desegregation has marched forward, and as corporations comprehend the extent to which black dollars are an integral component of their bottom line &mdash we see a kind of enlightened self-interest in the American corporate and business sectors,&rdquo stated Lolis Eric Elie, an African-American writer who has worked on numerous tv shows, including &ldquoTreme.&rdquo
The retailer closings came on the very same day that ABC Entertainment, the network that broadcast the hit reboot of Ms. Barr&rsquos sitcom, &ldquoRoseanne,&rdquo announced it was canceling the show, which had been noticed as an explicit outreach by a mainstream media business to Trump voters.
The announcement, which named Ms. Barr&rsquos tweet &ldquoabhorrent, repugnant and inconsistent with our values,&rdquo came from Channing Dungey, the ABC Entertainment president and the 1st black executive to run a significant network.
Published at Fri, 01 Jun 2018 21:07:24 +0000